Two Muslims attacked in one week by bigots (and the media)

Last week, two separate brutal attacks against Muslim men took place in Queens, New York.  On November 24th, 72-year-old Ali Akmal was nearly beaten to death while going on his early morning walk  and remains in critical, but stable, condition.

CBS New York reports:

Akmal’s tongue was so badly swollen that he couldn’t talk for two days. When he finally could, he told police that when he first encountered the two men, they asked him, “are you Muslim or Hindu?”

He responded “I’m Muslim,” and that’s when they attacked.

The beating was so savage and personal, Akmal was even bitten on the nose.

Just a few days earlier, 57-year-old Bashir Ahmad was beaten and stabbed repeatedly as he entered a mosque in Flushing, Queens early in the morning on November 19th. The attacker yelled anti-Muslim slurs at him, threatened to kill him, and also bit him on the nose.  Ahmad was hospitalized and received staples in his head and stitches in his leg.

These vicious attacks come just a few months after the white supremacist rampage that left six Sikhs dead in Oak Creek, Wisconsin in August, followed by a string of at least 10 separate anti-Muslim attacks around the country in the two weeks that followed.   And just over a year after the elderly Sikh men Gurmej Atwal and Surinder Singh were shot and killed on their evening walk in Elk Grove, California.

Needless to say, I was horrified last week when I heard about the attack on Ahmad and am even more horrified today after learning about Akmal, a grandfather, nearly being killed in this act of violent hatred a few days later.  The trauma of the Oak Creek shooting is still fresh for us Sikhs in, and there is little doubt that these recent attacks on Muslim men in Queens are rooted in the same type of bigotry that has so often made Sikhs targets since 9/11.  As I’ve said before, our struggles are deeply connected.

The way I heard about the attack on Ahmad last week, though, was almost as troubling as the attack itself.  I read this headline on NBC New York’s website:Queens Mosque Stabbing Victim Says He’d Retaliate if Given Chance.”

Before providing any details on what happened in the attack and why, the story leads off with, “A Muslim man who was stabbed as he tried to open the door to a Queens mosque says he will strike back if he ever sees his attacker.”

I read the headline and lead paragraph repeatedly; I could hardly believe what I was seeing.  A man was just beaten and stabbed in an obvious hate crime (the article mentions the anti-Muslim slurs), but the story is: “The Muslim may retaliate.”

The New York Post’s (notorious for its sensationalist pseudo-journalism, i.e. its “Turban Warfare” story) coverage of the incident was similar, leading off with:

 A devout Muslim man who was stabbed as he tried to open the door to a Queens mosque on Sunday says his hate-spewing attacker had better watch his back.

“If I see him again, I will kill him from 20 feet away,” 57-year-old Bashir Ahmad told The Post yesterday. “I will hurt him.”

I imagine I would be extremely emotional after such an attack as well, and while I have never been physically assaulted, I have experienced plenty of racist harassment, including my turban being pulled off on the NYC subway.  My emotions ran out of control in the minutes and hours after it happened—I was fuming with anger, rage, humiliation.  I guess I should consider myself lucky that no reporters were there. Apparently the anger of someone with brown skin and a beard makes a more exciting story for the media than the bleak reality of racist violence.

Perhaps we shouldn’t even be so surprised by these attacks when the media’s depictions of Muslims has become so biased.  American media—including Hollywood—have long portrayed Arabs and Muslims as barbaric, blood-thirsty caricatures. This five-minute clip from the documentary Reel Bad Arabs powerfully sums up the problem:

Now, things have apparently gotten so out of control that even after a Muslim man like Bashir Ahmad is victimized in such a horrific way, the take home message for the public is still that the Muslim is the aggressor, is suspicious, is a potential threat.

Not long ago, blackface and minstrel shows were commonplace in the US.  Racial justice activists worked tirelessly to push these sorts of bigoted depictions of Black folks to the margins and did so with great success (though the problem is far from solved).  We desperately need a similar movement today to uproot Islamophobia from the mass media.  Sikh organizations in the US (especially SALDEF, which was founded as SMART, the Sikh Mediawatch and Resource Task Force) have made some headway in the representations of Sikhs in the American media (though the Indian media is a whole other story), especially since 9/11.  Islamophobia in the media is just as much our issue, and I hope to see our organizations and sangats taking up this cause as our own.

bookmark bookmark bookmark bookmark bookmark bookmark bookmark bookmark bookmark bookmark bookmark bookmark

18 Responses to “Two Muslims attacked in one week by bigots (and the media)”

  1. ninachanpreet says:

    the roots and seeds are the same. our sikh orgs have failed to do the type of mediawatch SMART (now SALDEF) used to do – it's not only mediawatch but partnership with our brothers and sisters across faiths and race to contradict and counteract the issue. we will make no progress alone, as comfortable as our community sometimes is being so insular.

  2. Sanehval says:

    I'll puppet the voice of the conservatives on the blog:
    Is there a Muslim progressive blog that pays as much attention to their Sikh 'brothers and sisters' as this one does to its Muslim brothers and sisters?

  3. Deep Hundal says:


    During our Guru's period, did any Hindu leaders ever give their heads for the right of Sikhs to practice their faith?

    It doesn't matter if they did or did not, what matters is our reaction to oppression of others.

  4. […] appearances and tautological messages let’s attack the roots of xenophobia, hate, racism and the media that breeds it. Although education alone will not dispel white supremacy, we are in dire need of large scale […]

  5. […] Nina Chanpreet Kaur provides an in depth contextual critique of the Kony 2012-like “Be Proud” media campaign, launched recently at the Sikh International Film Festival in New York by entrepreneur millionaire Gurbaksh Chahal in response to the mass murder of Sikhs in Oak Creek, Wisconsin: Truly empowering people and eliminating hate comes with massive, localized, collaborative efforts aligned with existing national efforts that are measurable, focused on skill and community building, and impact the day to day lives of communities. Starting a massive media campaign to raise awareness about an issue is a fine beginning. What about curriculum, training and community events to follow? What about tracking the effectiveness of those efforts? In fact, instead of media appearances and tautological messages let’s attack the roots of xenophobia, hate, racism and the media that breeds it. […]

  6. […] and tautological messages let’s attack the roots of xenophobia, hate, racism and the media that breeds it. …From siloed, insular, ego driven and territorial alliances to deeply collaborative, […]

  7. Reading a good book or reading any other useful novel is not only education. Education is the name of continuous learning different things from the different aspects and angles to get result of about it.