The Indian Disconnect

In a process that took three decades, Sajjan Kumar, a leader in India's Congress Party, was recently acquitted for his well-documented involvement in the anti-Sikh pogroms during November 1984 in which thousands of Sikhs were murdered in three days in the country's capital city. Five co-accused were convicted. (Source: Live Mint)

In a process that took three decades, Sajjan Kumar, a leader in India’s Congress Party, was recently acquitted for his well-documented involvement in the anti-Sikh pogroms during November 1984 in which thousands of Sikhs were murdered in three days in the country’s capital city. Five co-accused were convicted. (Source: Live Mint)

About two months ago, I observed the continuing engagement by representatives of the Indian government with the Sikh American community, which in that instance took the form of an exhibition on Sikh heritage in Atlanta, Georgia, sponsored by the Government of India. This exhibit has just recently been presented in Washington, D.C., as well, and it is consistent with increased engagement and activity related to the Sikh American community — be it directly, or through lobbying of US officials — by representatives of India. The increasing effort by Indian officials to promote the Sikh community in the United States is problematic, however, as it runs contrary to India’s track record with the Sikhs in its own borders over the past several decades.

Whether in the aftermath of a hate crime (such as in Oak Creek, Wisconsin, or recently in Fresno, California), or in what appears a deliberate attempt to brand the Sikh identity with Indian nationalism, representatives of the Indian government are insisting that they be the custodians of the Sikh community in the United States.

To an observer unaware of context, there would seem nothing out of the ordinary with such engagement by representatives of the Government of India. Historically, Sikhs originated in the Punjab area of what is now Pakistan and India, and since the Partition of British India in 1947 to create those countries, the majority of the world’s Sikh population resides in India. Many Sikh Americans have strong ties to Punjab on both religious and personal bases. And, certainly, as India’s Ambassador to the United States recently wrote to me on Twitter, there is a role for the Embassy in protecting the interests of Indian nationals — presumably, this includes Hindus, Muslims, Sikhs, Buddhists, Christians and others — in the United States. (It must be remembered, of course, that many Sikhs and others have no proximate ethnic or familial ties to India — having adopted Sikhism later in life or having been born and brought up in the United States, in some cases for several generations.)

It is not difficult to see where this expression of solidarity with Sikh Americans is problematic, and where this role presents a conflict for India’s representatives.

When India’s representatives in the United States are hosting “Sikh heritage” exhibitions to promote the Sikh people as “the shield of India,” or insisting on their place in addressing Sikh American civil rights issues such as hate crimes and discrimination, this activity is in stark contrast with the Indian Government’s own well-documented participation and lack of responsibility around the severest of human rights abuses of Indian nationals within its own borders. Specifically, in but one example, India has itself failed to adequately address the horror of the anti-Sikh pogroms in November, 1984, when thousands of Sikhs were butchered, burned alive and raped in the streets of Delhi in just three days by organized and unfettered mobs. From complacency to active participation, government officials and police agencies have long been implicated, and various human rights organizations (such as Human Rights Watch and Amnesty International) have lamented both India’s refusal to administer justice for the surviving victims and its protecting of government officials who were responsible. In fact, even the US Council for International Religious Freedom continues to track India for its failure to administer justice for these abuses towards its religious communities. Recently, the White House itself asserted its condemnation of the anti-Sikh pogroms of 1984.

In this disconnect between the stances taken related to the Sikhs in India versus the Sikhs in the United States, the recent public relations effort appears as little more than a propaganda campaign to maintain a colonial ownership over the Sikh American community — one that is slowly increasing in prominence and organization. It is difficult to see these efforts as more. There is nary a mention by Indian officials in the United States of the more recent history of suffering of the Sikhs during 1984 and beyond, nor is there any concern shown for the obfuscation of justice in India towards Sikh and other communities that still continues today. For India’s representatives in the United States to “promote Sikh heritage” on one hand, and deny recent and painful Sikh history on the other (and attempt to deflect attention by defaming anyone who nonviolently raises concern about human rights as a terrorist or extremist), is certainly a scenario that begs many questions.

If representatives of the Indian government wish to present themselves as allies of the Sikh American community, they must start by first becoming so for the Sikhs in India. Until justice for large-scale and decades-old human rights abuses exacted by complicit governments, agencies and officials towards Sikhs in India is achieved, it is difficult to accept with any legitimacy the overtures made towards the Sikh community in the United States.

[Cross-posted on American Turban]


bookmark bookmark bookmark bookmark bookmark bookmark bookmark bookmark bookmark bookmark bookmark bookmark
tabs-top


13 Responses to “The Indian Disconnect”

  1. SINGH says:

    SAT SRI AKAL,

    AS LONG AS THE WHITEMAN PROMOTES FEMINISM, ALL THIS IS IRRELEVANT!!!!

  2. Sher says:

    Question to American Turban and other like minded kharkus, Singhs and plain Sikhs: Is Sikhi only about the 'human rights' of radical Khalsas? did those killed by your kharkus (terrorists for the othes) had any human rights too? Do Sacha Sauda Premis being persecuted in Punjab TODAY have any human rights? do the Nirankaris, Radha Soamis, Hindus, Mazhabis, Noormehliya …have the basic right to follow their own faith in Punjab?

    PS: Moderators, so f word can be used on this forum, is that correct?

  3. Sher says:

    "If representatives of the Indian government wish to present themselves as allies of the Sikh American community, they must start by first becoming so for the Sikhs in India. Until justice for large-scale and decades-old human rights abuses exacted by complicit governments, agencies and officials towards Sikhs in India is achieved, it is difficult to accept with any legitimacy the overtures made towards the Sikh community in the United States"

    Are you alleging that Indian government is not an ally of Indian Sikhs?!!

    Massive, overwhelming majority of Sikhs in India participate in various democratic activities like any other citizen of India. Sikhs continue to be among the most prosperous community in India and are over-represented in almost every sphere of life inc PM and the Army Chief. six-seven years back we had Congress government in Punjab.

    Khalistani Sikhs, on the other hand, always fail to find any legs to stand on. They are routed in every electoral exercise. in other words, khalistan option has been rejected by the Punjab Sikhs. Do not even bother asking Sikhs living outside Punjab. They are enjoying the freedom not afforded to minorities (Dear Sacha sauda, mazhabis, Nirankaris, Noormehlias, etc.) in Punjab.

    I agree with your assertion about the human rights abuses by various governmental agencies but what about the HR abuses by the Sikh terrorists? Majority of their victims, let me remind you, were sikhs! Forget the terror victims from other communities (often dismissed as collateral damage by radical Khalsas) but at least show some compassion for your own.

    Amazing, biased ppl like you would flash the victim card and remind the world about Wisconsin atrocity but would always shrug when someone mentions Air India bombing which killed 332 civilians.

  4. To interact with different community members and to meet other society you have to learn knowledge and get an education for enhancing your capabilities to avail those chances which education provides that is necessary for the interaction process. During interaction with different people we gain more than thoughts.

  5. arslan672 says:

    In the event you’re contemplating buying the latest vehicle, you will be confused together with frustrated when facing deciding concerning a manufacturer’s reimburse and 0% finance. Despite that 0% finance seems far more desirable versus actual ex-, there isn’t almost any denying the exact tremendous selling point of using this manufacturer’s rebate such as a down payment jointly with a low-interest rate car loan package from your neighborhood bank or perhaps credit marital life. http://www.mindanaomicrofinance.org

  6. arslan672 says:

    In the event you’re contemplating buying the latest vehicle, you will be confused together with frustrated when facing deciding concerning a manufacturer’s reimburse and 0% finance. Despite that 0% finance seems far more desirable versus actual ex-, there isn’t almost any denying the exact tremendous selling point of using this manufacturer’s rebate such as a down payment jointly with a low-interest rate car loan package from your neighborhood bank or perhaps credit marital life. http://www.mindanaomicrofinance.org

  7. arslan672 says:

    When a successful replacement becomes necessary by entrepreneurs for small enterprise finance services previously by banks, there are various business finance choices to take into consideration. An more and more prudent alternative is made for small companies to get whether you'll discover effective manufacturing finance options to vary bank finance before they’re basically required mainly because industrial borrowers is likely to hear various reports about the growing issues in having loans from banks. http://www.dehchotravel.org

  8. arslan672 says:

    each time traveling in another country, one will most likely always take in consideration good and low-priced international traveling cover. Travel insurances have grown essential as soon as vacationing. Many vacation companies and insurers have coincided in order to make sure they give the customers when using the superb service they sincerely deserve. http://www.travelingsenecatrail.org

  9. arslan672 says:

    Some sort of 20 year term life insurance plan delivers comprehensive coverage to your insurer by pre-fixed selling price. This is performed for stipulated timeframe. Once your message period of two full decades expires, coverage in the previous rate-of-premiums seems to lose its reassure. http://www.lifeinsuranceadvisors.org

  10. arslan672 says:

    There’s a large technology have an effect on that’s amongst the future. There will also be no mistake men and women do need when using the robotics technological know-how curriculum for getting us begun. Many on the youngsters which might be on college or university, college and many others is competent to use the exact robotic technologies for getting on in conjunction with things in life. http://www.ameiseonline.org

  11. arslan672 says:

    This immediate commitment regarding senior management as well as participation regarding employees in the development regarding workplace well-being policies are a vital prerequisite to your successful execution of policies that could address the exact needs on the working local community. http://www.easyhealthed.org