![]()
![]()
Lohiri Celebration: Girls and Boys?
Posted by Phulkari in General on 01 17th, 2008 | 54 responses
Recently I attended a Lohiri Party celebrating the birth of a baby boy. Complete with bhangra, ghidda, food in the garage, a fire in the backyard, peanuts, rarroya, ladies in the family room, and the Babujis in the living room. While there I had a conversation with the new bride in the family about Lohiri. Our family friend’s son had married a
Did anyone recently attend a Lohiri Party for a baby girl or a girl’s marriage this year? What are your thoughts after attending any type of Lohiri celebration this season!
Logging you in...
Trinjan Punjabi Folk Academy in Surrey, BC, Canada celebrates a Kuri Mundeyan Di Lohri, "Girls & Boys Lohri" each year.
More info at trinjan.org
More info at trinjan.org
Trinjan Punjabi Folk Academy in Surrey, BC, Canada celebrates a Kuri Mundeyan Di Lohri, "Girls & Boys Lohri" each year.
More info at trinjan.org
More info at trinjan.org
The last two Lohris I attended were for a baby girl and a baby boy, respectively (the former was in India, the latter in the U.S.). It was kind of a "first baby" celebration, which I thought was nice :) I actually never grew up with a strong Lohri-attending family, so I never really understood what it was all about (or why it was considered, by some, objectionable) until I was much older. I have a feeling interpretations of who a Lohri is "for" vary by the couple and family, no?
I have not had a chance to attend any Lohri celebrations this year, but I had an interesting convo with some friends who were staunch rivals of celebrating lohri for their newlyborn nephew when nothing of the sort had been celebrated for their older nieces. Ultimately, they decided to get together with family and do Sukhmani Sahib to celebrate the arrival of a baby and said that this is how they would continue to celebrate births (with peanuts and ryorian afterwards of course). Also, there was a clause in their verbal agreement that required the family to retroactively hold gatherings for the two nieces. So - they decided on equality.
I have not attended many lohri celebrations either; however, I do recall a lohri celebration held for my brother and myself in India.
This was our first trip to India, and the extended family decided it was high time to hold a lohri celebration for us. My parents had no objections.
However, when the party started, my parents, especially my father, made it abundantly clear the lohri was for my sister as well and he made sure she was a part of the festivities. This was some 20 years ago or so. On a similar note, when my sister was born, father insisted on distributing ladoos to everyone, and held a huge party to celebrate her birth - this was over 2 decades ago.
Maybe pops was a little ahead of his time, but I am hopeful he wasn't the only one. Perhaps I'm being overly optimistic, but it seems as if the trend, in N.America at least, is shifting a little more towards boy-and-girl lohri parties.
This was our first trip to India, and the extended family decided it was high time to hold a lohri celebration for us. My parents had no objections.
However, when the party started, my parents, especially my father, made it abundantly clear the lohri was for my sister as well and he made sure she was a part of the festivities. This was some 20 years ago or so. On a similar note, when my sister was born, father insisted on distributing ladoos to everyone, and held a huge party to celebrate her birth - this was over 2 decades ago.
Maybe pops was a little ahead of his time, but I am hopeful he wasn't the only one. Perhaps I'm being overly optimistic, but it seems as if the trend, in N.America at least, is shifting a little more towards boy-and-girl lohri parties.
I recently spoke to my sister in-law in India and she actually told me that people celebrate Lohri for girls out there all the time. I was really excited to hear this news.
Unfortunately, I did not here of any Lohri celebrations done for girls here in California. In fact, my cousin recently had a daughter and refused to celebrate for her. But of course, she did so when she had her son two years ago. When I mentioned to my own mom that I will celebrate Lohri for my daughter, she just became angry and told me not to say that in front of other people.
I think changing the Lohri tradition is completely up to us, the new generation. If we brake these traditions, it will seem odd to future generations that Lohri was celebrated just for boys. Also, this will encourage the people who do not celebrate Lohri for girls to do so because of course no Punjabi likes to be the outcast. So lets reverse this whole thinking on those that don't appreciate the birth of little girls.
Unfortunately, I did not here of any Lohri celebrations done for girls here in California. In fact, my cousin recently had a daughter and refused to celebrate for her. But of course, she did so when she had her son two years ago. When I mentioned to my own mom that I will celebrate Lohri for my daughter, she just became angry and told me not to say that in front of other people.
I think changing the Lohri tradition is completely up to us, the new generation. If we brake these traditions, it will seem odd to future generations that Lohri was celebrated just for boys. Also, this will encourage the people who do not celebrate Lohri for girls to do so because of course no Punjabi likes to be the outcast. So lets reverse this whole thinking on those that don't appreciate the birth of little girls.
The last two Lohris I attended were for a baby girl and a baby boy, respectively (the former was in India, the latter in the U.S.). It was kind of a "first baby" celebration, which I thought was nice :) I actually never grew up with a strong Lohri-attending family, so I never really understood what it was all about (or why it was considered, by some, objectionable) until I was much older. I have a feeling interpretations of who a Lohri is "for" vary by the couple and family, no?
I have not had a chance to attend any Lohri celebrations this year, but I had an interesting convo with some friends who were staunch rivals of celebrating lohri for their newlyborn nephew when nothing of the sort had been celebrated for their older nieces. Ultimately, they decided to get together with family and do Sukhmani Sahib to celebrate the arrival of a baby and said that this is how they would continue to celebrate births (with peanuts and ryorian afterwards of course). Also, there was a clause in their verbal agreement that required the family to retroactively hold gatherings for the two nieces. So - they decided on equality.
I have not attended many lohri celebrations either; however, I do recall a lohri celebration held for my brother and myself in India.
This was our first trip to India, and the extended family decided it was high time to hold a lohri celebration for us. My parents had no objections.
However, when the party started, my parents, especially my father, made it abundantly clear the lohri was for my sister as well and he made sure she was a part of the festivities. This was some 20 years ago or so. On a similar note, when my sister was born, father insisted on distributing ladoos to everyone, and held a huge party to celebrate her birth - this was over 2 decades ago.
Maybe pops was a little ahead of his time, but I am hopeful he wasn't the only one. Perhaps I'm being overly optimistic, but it seems as if the trend, in N.America at least, is shifting a little more towards boy-and-girl lohri parties.
This was our first trip to India, and the extended family decided it was high time to hold a lohri celebration for us. My parents had no objections.
However, when the party started, my parents, especially my father, made it abundantly clear the lohri was for my sister as well and he made sure she was a part of the festivities. This was some 20 years ago or so. On a similar note, when my sister was born, father insisted on distributing ladoos to everyone, and held a huge party to celebrate her birth - this was over 2 decades ago.
Maybe pops was a little ahead of his time, but I am hopeful he wasn't the only one. Perhaps I'm being overly optimistic, but it seems as if the trend, in N.America at least, is shifting a little more towards boy-and-girl lohri parties.
i attented lots of lohris all where for boys
i to celebrated for my son and not for my daughter i always thought lohri was only for boys because its was so we where taught and bought up to believe this, its got that people now celebrate for daughters too
i too thing that boys and girls should be treated same but like everything change takes time its happening slowly, its like everything you will find people that will not agree with the change...
i to celebrated for my son and not for my daughter i always thought lohri was only for boys because its was so we where taught and bought up to believe this, its got that people now celebrate for daughters too
i too thing that boys and girls should be treated same but like everything change takes time its happening slowly, its like everything you will find people that will not agree with the change...
I recently spoke to my sister in-law in India and she actually told me that people celebrate Lohri for girls out there all the time. I was really excited to hear this news.
Unfortunately, I did not here of any Lohri celebrations done for girls here in California. In fact, my cousin recently had a daughter and refused to celebrate for her. But of course, she did so when she had her son two years ago. When I mentioned to my own mom that I will celebrate Lohri for my daughter, she just became angry and told me not to say that in front of other people.
I think changing the Lohri tradition is completely up to us, the new generation. If we brake these traditions, it will seem odd to future generations that Lohri was celebrated just for boys. Also, this will encourage the people who do not celebrate Lohri for girls to do so because of course no Punjabi likes to be the outcast. So lets reverse this whole thinking on those that don't appreciate the birth of little girls.
Unfortunately, I did not here of any Lohri celebrations done for girls here in California. In fact, my cousin recently had a daughter and refused to celebrate for her. But of course, she did so when she had her son two years ago. When I mentioned to my own mom that I will celebrate Lohri for my daughter, she just became angry and told me not to say that in front of other people.
I think changing the Lohri tradition is completely up to us, the new generation. If we brake these traditions, it will seem odd to future generations that Lohri was celebrated just for boys. Also, this will encourage the people who do not celebrate Lohri for girls to do so because of course no Punjabi likes to be the outcast. So lets reverse this whole thinking on those that don't appreciate the birth of little girls.
...so much for my optimism....a Punjabi guy who lives about 5 mins away from me, killed his baby girl today.
As per desi news, it appears he had two daughters already, but wanted a son. When his wife was pregnant for the third time, he pushed her to get an abortion, but she refused, and a baby girl was born. From there, the guy became depressed, and apparently quit his job.
Today, when the mother was gone to drop her two older daughters at school, the guy stabbed his baby girl to death.
I'm at a loss for words - disgust, anger, sadness, none of these seem sufficient.
As per desi news, it appears he had two daughters already, but wanted a son. When his wife was pregnant for the third time, he pushed her to get an abortion, but she refused, and a baby girl was born. From there, the guy became depressed, and apparently quit his job.
Today, when the mother was gone to drop her two older daughters at school, the guy stabbed his baby girl to death.
I'm at a loss for words - disgust, anger, sadness, none of these seem sufficient.
i attented lots of lohris all where for boys
i to celebrated for my son and not for my daughter i always thought lohri was only for boys because its was so we where taught and bought up to believe this, its got that people now celebrate for daughters too
i too thing that boys and girls should be treated same but like everything change takes time its happening slowly, its like everything you will find people that will not agree with the change...
i to celebrated for my son and not for my daughter i always thought lohri was only for boys because its was so we where taught and bought up to believe this, its got that people now celebrate for daughters too
i too thing that boys and girls should be treated same but like everything change takes time its happening slowly, its like everything you will find people that will not agree with the change...
When will this stop? seriously.
Link to the story P.Singh mentioned.
<a href="http://www.canada.com/vancouversun/news/story.html" target="_blank">http://www.canada.com/vancouversun/news/story.htm...
Link to the story P.Singh mentioned.
<a href="http://www.canada.com/vancouversun/news/story.html" target="_blank">http://www.canada.com/vancouversun/news/story.htm...
P. Singh, are there any groups in Vancouver that can/will respond to this? Do you think the neighborhood will be able to provide support for the mother and daughters? Do they have other family nearby?
I had a baby girl here in US couple of yrs ago, but my parents in India celebrated her first Lohri (we were not able to go). We don't believe in too much pomp and show, but they invited a few close relatives, had dinner, celebrated Lohri. No music DJs or big party. Mobile Dhol wala came in, people danced to the Dhol.... Thats exactly we would have celebrated if we had a boy.
...so much for my optimism....a Punjabi guy who lives about 5 mins away from me, killed his baby girl today.
As per desi news, it appears he had two daughters already, but wanted a son. When his wife was pregnant for the third time, he pushed her to get an abortion, but she refused, and a baby girl was born. From there, the guy became depressed, and apparently quit his job.
Today, when the mother was gone to drop her two older daughters at school, the guy stabbed his baby girl to death.
I'm at a loss for words - disgust, anger, sadness, none of these seem sufficient.
As per desi news, it appears he had two daughters already, but wanted a son. When his wife was pregnant for the third time, he pushed her to get an abortion, but she refused, and a baby girl was born. From there, the guy became depressed, and apparently quit his job.
Today, when the mother was gone to drop her two older daughters at school, the guy stabbed his baby girl to death.
I'm at a loss for words - disgust, anger, sadness, none of these seem sufficient.
When will this stop? seriously.
Link to the story P.Singh mentioned.
http://www.canada.com/vancouversun/news/story.htm...
Link to the story P.Singh mentioned.
http://www.canada.com/vancouversun/news/story.htm...
P. Singh, are there any groups in Vancouver that can/will respond to this? Do you think the neighborhood will be able to provide support for the mother and daughters? Do they have other family nearby?
I had a baby girl here in US couple of yrs ago, but my parents in India celebrated her first Lohri (we were not able to go). We don't believe in too much pomp and show, but they invited a few close relatives, had dinner, celebrated Lohri. No music DJs or big party. Mobile Dhol wala came in, people danced to the Dhol.... Thats exactly we would have celebrated if we had a boy.
Reema,
I am not aware if there is any family close-at-hand, but would be surprised if there wasn't some family, given the large Punjabi community in nearby cities.
I'm sure indo-canadian women's rights groups will say their piece to the media, and people will make speeches in gurdwaras, and perhaps there will be town-hall type meetings, where politicians and 'community-leaders' will gather to give yet more speeches (and take advantage of photo ops) - the same kind of response that took place 1 or 2 years ago, after a string of domestic violence related incidents made headlines in B.C.
Given that such little concrete work was done after the then 'hot issue' of domestic violence cooled down, I have little confidence our community will take any steps after the current 'hot issue' of this murdered baby girl cools down.
After all, its just one more murdered baby girl to add to all the others, right? Although, I guess killing baby girls via prenatal sex selection is probably the better way of going about things - less problems with the cops that way.
I am not aware if there is any family close-at-hand, but would be surprised if there wasn't some family, given the large Punjabi community in nearby cities.
I'm sure indo-canadian women's rights groups will say their piece to the media, and people will make speeches in gurdwaras, and perhaps there will be town-hall type meetings, where politicians and 'community-leaders' will gather to give yet more speeches (and take advantage of photo ops) - the same kind of response that took place 1 or 2 years ago, after a string of domestic violence related incidents made headlines in B.C.
Given that such little concrete work was done after the then 'hot issue' of domestic violence cooled down, I have little confidence our community will take any steps after the current 'hot issue' of this murdered baby girl cools down.
After all, its just one more murdered baby girl to add to all the others, right? Although, I guess killing baby girls via prenatal sex selection is probably the better way of going about things - less problems with the cops that way.
Reema,
I am not aware if there is any family close-at-hand, but would be surprised if there wasn't some family, given the large Punjabi community in nearby cities.
I'm sure indo-canadian women's rights groups will say their piece to the media, and people will make speeches in gurdwaras, and perhaps there will be town-hall type meetings, where politicians and 'community-leaders' will gather to give yet more speeches (and take advantage of photo ops) - the same kind of response that took place 1 or 2 years ago, after a string of domestic violence related incidents made headlines in B.C.
Given that such little concrete work was done after the then 'hot issue' of domestic violence cooled down, I have little confidence our community will take any steps after the current 'hot issue' of this murdered baby girl cools down.
After all, its just one more murdered baby girl to add to all the others, right? Although, I guess killing baby girls via prenatal sex selection is probably the better way of going about things - less problems with the cops that way.
I am not aware if there is any family close-at-hand, but would be surprised if there wasn't some family, given the large Punjabi community in nearby cities.
I'm sure indo-canadian women's rights groups will say their piece to the media, and people will make speeches in gurdwaras, and perhaps there will be town-hall type meetings, where politicians and 'community-leaders' will gather to give yet more speeches (and take advantage of photo ops) - the same kind of response that took place 1 or 2 years ago, after a string of domestic violence related incidents made headlines in B.C.
Given that such little concrete work was done after the then 'hot issue' of domestic violence cooled down, I have little confidence our community will take any steps after the current 'hot issue' of this murdered baby girl cools down.
After all, its just one more murdered baby girl to add to all the others, right? Although, I guess killing baby girls via prenatal sex selection is probably the better way of going about things - less problems with the cops that way.
Reema and Puneet,
I am the first to complain of the lack of community response that extends beyond photo ops and speeches. So let us come up with some 'concrete' suggestions that can be implemented. What would we do in BC? What should we be doing in our own communities? What are some 'concrete' plans and ideas?
I am the first to complain of the lack of community response that extends beyond photo ops and speeches. So let us come up with some 'concrete' suggestions that can be implemented. What would we do in BC? What should we be doing in our own communities? What are some 'concrete' plans and ideas?
Reema and Puneet,
I am the first to complain of the lack of community response that extends beyond photo ops and speeches. So let us come up with some 'concrete' suggestions that can be implemented. What would we do in BC? What should we be doing in our own communities? What are some 'concrete' plans and ideas?
I am the first to complain of the lack of community response that extends beyond photo ops and speeches. So let us come up with some 'concrete' suggestions that can be implemented. What would we do in BC? What should we be doing in our own communities? What are some 'concrete' plans and ideas?
I am just left speech-less about P.Singh's story. How could any human being stab a poor innocent child? I hope those people face the hell they have choosen for themselves.
Post a new comment
Not displayed publicly.
Not displayed publicly.
Comments are welcome. This space is intended as a forum for open discussion. However, we will edit or remove comments we find inappropriate, at our discretion. No profanity, name-calling, discrimination, or hate will be tolerated, whether directed towards another commenter, a blogger, or an individual or group not directly present on TLH.
Comments by IntenseDebate
Loading IntenseDebate Comments...
Trinjan Punjabi Folk Academy in Surrey, BC, Canada celebrates a Kuri Mundeyan Di Lohri, "Girls & Boys Lohri" each year.
More info at trinjan.org
Trinjan Punjabi Folk Academy in Surrey, BC, Canada celebrates a Kuri Mundeyan Di Lohri, “Girls & Boys Lohri” each year.
More info at trinjan.org
The last two Lohris I attended were for a baby girl and a baby boy, respectively (the former was in India, the latter in the U.S.). It was kind of a "first baby" celebration, which I thought was nice
I actually never grew up with a strong Lohri-attending family, so I never really understood what it was all about (or why it was considered, by some, objectionable) until I was much older. I have a feeling interpretations of who a Lohri is "for" vary by the couple and family, no?
The last two Lohris I attended were for a baby girl and a baby boy, respectively (the former was in India, the latter in the U.S.). It was kind of a “first baby” celebration, which I thought was nice
I actually never grew up with a strong Lohri-attending family, so I never really understood what it was all about (or why it was considered, by some, objectionable) until I was much older. I have a feeling interpretations of who a Lohri is “for” vary by the couple and family, no?
I have not had a chance to attend any Lohri celebrations this year, but I had an interesting convo with some friends who were staunch rivals of celebrating lohri for their newlyborn nephew when nothing of the sort had been celebrated for their older nieces. Ultimately, they decided to get together with family and do Sukhmani Sahib to celebrate the arrival of a baby and said that this is how they would continue to celebrate births (with peanuts and ryorian afterwards of course). Also, there was a clause in their verbal agreement that required the family to retroactively hold gatherings for the two nieces. So – they decided on equality.
I have not had a chance to attend any Lohri celebrations this year, but I had an interesting convo with some friends who were staunch rivals of celebrating lohri for their newlyborn nephew when nothing of the sort had been celebrated for their older nieces. Ultimately, they decided to get together with family and do Sukhmani Sahib to celebrate the arrival of a baby and said that this is how they would continue to celebrate births (with peanuts and ryorian afterwards of course). Also, there was a clause in their verbal agreement that required the family to retroactively hold gatherings for the two nieces. So – they decided on equality.
I have not attended many lohri celebrations either; however, I do recall a lohri celebration held for my brother and myself in India.
This was our first trip to India, and the extended family decided it was high time to hold a lohri celebration for us. My parents had no objections.
However, when the party started, my parents, especially my father, made it abundantly clear the lohri was for my sister as well and he made sure she was a part of the festivities. This was some 20 years ago or so. On a similar note, when my sister was born, father insisted on distributing ladoos to everyone, and held a huge party to celebrate her birth – this was over 2 decades ago.
Maybe pops was a little ahead of his time, but I am hopeful he wasn't the only one. Perhaps I'm being overly optimistic, but it seems as if the trend, in N.America at least, is shifting a little more towards boy-and-girl lohri parties.
I have not attended many lohri celebrations either; however, I do recall a lohri celebration held for my brother and myself in India.
This was our first trip to India, and the extended family decided it was high time to hold a lohri celebration for us. My parents had no objections.
However, when the party started, my parents, especially my father, made it abundantly clear the lohri was for my sister as well and he made sure she was a part of the festivities. This was some 20 years ago or so. On a similar note, when my sister was born, father insisted on distributing ladoos to everyone, and held a huge party to celebrate her birth – this was over 2 decades ago.
Maybe pops was a little ahead of his time, but I am hopeful he wasn’t the only one. Perhaps I’m being overly optimistic, but it seems as if the trend, in N.America at least, is shifting a little more towards boy-and-girl lohri parties.
I recently spoke to my sister in-law in India and she actually told me that people celebrate Lohri for girls out there all the time. I was really excited to hear this news.
Unfortunately, I did not here of any Lohri celebrations done for girls here in California. In fact, my cousin recently had a daughter and refused to celebrate for her. But of course, she did so when she had her son two years ago. When I mentioned to my own mom that I will celebrate Lohri for my daughter, she just became angry and told me not to say that in front of other people.
I think changing the Lohri tradition is completely up to us, the new generation. If we brake these traditions, it will seem odd to future generations that Lohri was celebrated just for boys. Also, this will encourage the people who do not celebrate Lohri for girls to do so because of course no Punjabi likes to be the outcast. So lets reverse this whole thinking on those that don't appreciate the birth of little girls.
I recently spoke to my sister in-law in India and she actually told me that people celebrate Lohri for girls out there all the time. I was really excited to hear this news.
Unfortunately, I did not here of any Lohri celebrations done for girls here in California. In fact, my cousin recently had a daughter and refused to celebrate for her. But of course, she did so when she had her son two years ago. When I mentioned to my own mom that I will celebrate Lohri for my daughter, she just became angry and told me not to say that in front of other people.
I think changing the Lohri tradition is completely up to us, the new generation. If we brake these traditions, it will seem odd to future generations that Lohri was celebrated just for boys. Also, this will encourage the people who do not celebrate Lohri for girls to do so because of course no Punjabi likes to be the outcast. So lets reverse this whole thinking on those that don’t appreciate the birth of little girls.
i attented lots of lohris all where for boys
i to celebrated for my son and not for my daughter i always thought lohri was only for boys because its was so we where taught and bought up to believe this, its got that people now celebrate for daughters too
i too thing that boys and girls should be treated same but like everything change takes time its happening slowly, its like everything you will find people that will not agree with the change…
i attented lots of lohris all where for boys
i to celebrated for my son and not for my daughter i always thought lohri was only for boys because its was so we where taught and bought up to believe this, its got that people now celebrate for daughters too
i too thing that boys and girls should be treated same but like everything change takes time its happening slowly, its like everything you will find people that will not agree with the change…
…so much for my optimism….a Punjabi guy who lives about 5 mins away from me, killed his baby girl today.
As per desi news, it appears he had two daughters already, but wanted a son. When his wife was pregnant for the third time, he pushed her to get an abortion, but she refused, and a baby girl was born. From there, the guy became depressed, and apparently quit his job.
Today, when the mother was gone to drop her two older daughters at school, the guy stabbed his baby girl to death.
I'm at a loss for words – disgust, anger, sadness, none of these seem sufficient.
…so much for my optimism….a Punjabi guy who lives about 5 mins away from me, killed his baby girl today.
As per desi news, it appears he had two daughters already, but wanted a son. When his wife was pregnant for the third time, he pushed her to get an abortion, but she refused, and a baby girl was born. From there, the guy became depressed, and apparently quit his job.
Today, when the mother was gone to drop her two older daughters at school, the guy stabbed his baby girl to death.
I’m at a loss for words – disgust, anger, sadness, none of these seem sufficient.
When will this stop? seriously.
Link to the story P.Singh mentioned.
http://www.canada.com/vancouversun/news/story.htm…
When will this stop? seriously.
Link to the story P.Singh mentioned.
http://www.canada.com/vancouversun/news/story.html
P. Singh, are there any groups in Vancouver that can/will respond to this? Do you think the neighborhood will be able to provide support for the mother and daughters? Do they have other family nearby?
P. Singh, are there any groups in Vancouver that can/will respond to this? Do you think the neighborhood will be able to provide support for the mother and daughters? Do they have other family nearby?
I had a baby girl here in US couple of yrs ago, but my parents in India celebrated her first Lohri (we were not able to go). We don't believe in too much pomp and show, but they invited a few close relatives, had dinner, celebrated Lohri. No music DJs or big party. Mobile Dhol wala came in, people danced to the Dhol…. Thats exactly we would have celebrated if we had a boy.
I had a baby girl here in US couple of yrs ago, but my parents in India celebrated her first Lohri (we were not able to go). We don’t believe in too much pomp and show, but they invited a few close relatives, had dinner, celebrated Lohri. No music DJs or big party. Mobile Dhol wala came in, people danced to the Dhol…. Thats exactly we would have celebrated if we had a boy.
Reema,
I am not aware if there is any family close-at-hand, but would be surprised if there wasn't some family, given the large Punjabi community in nearby cities.
I'm sure indo-canadian women's rights groups will say their piece to the media, and people will make speeches in gurdwaras, and perhaps there will be town-hall type meetings, where politicians and 'community-leaders' will gather to give yet more speeches (and take advantage of photo ops) – the same kind of response that took place 1 or 2 years ago, after a string of domestic violence related incidents made headlines in B.C.
Given that such little concrete work was done after the then 'hot issue' of domestic violence cooled down, I have little confidence our community will take any steps after the current 'hot issue' of this murdered baby girl cools down.
After all, its just one more murdered baby girl to add to all the others, right? Although, I guess killing baby girls via prenatal sex selection is probably the better way of going about things – less problems with the cops that way.
Reema,
I am not aware if there is any family close-at-hand, but would be surprised if there wasn’t some family, given the large Punjabi community in nearby cities.
I’m sure indo-canadian women’s rights groups will say their piece to the media, and people will make speeches in gurdwaras, and perhaps there will be town-hall type meetings, where politicians and ‘community-leaders’ will gather to give yet more speeches (and take advantage of photo ops) – the same kind of response that took place 1 or 2 years ago, after a string of domestic violence related incidents made headlines in B.C.
Given that such little concrete work was done after the then ‘hot issue’ of domestic violence cooled down, I have little confidence our community will take any steps after the current ‘hot issue’ of this murdered baby girl cools down.
After all, its just one more murdered baby girl to add to all the others, right? Although, I guess killing baby girls via prenatal sex selection is probably the better way of going about things – less problems with the cops that way.
Reema and Puneet,
I am the first to complain of the lack of community response that extends beyond photo ops and speeches. So let us come up with some 'concrete' suggestions that can be implemented. What would we do in BC? What should we be doing in our own communities? What are some 'concrete' plans and ideas?
Reema and Puneet,
I am the first to complain of the lack of community response that extends beyond photo ops and speeches. So let us come up with some ‘concrete’ suggestions that can be implemented. What would we do in BC? What should we be doing in our own communities? What are some ‘concrete’ plans and ideas?
I am just left speech-less about P.Singh's story. How could any human being stab a poor innocent child? I hope those people face the hell they have choosen for themselves.
I am just left speech-less about P.Singh’s story. How could any human being stab a poor innocent child? I hope those people face the hell they have choosen for themselves.
tough question. i would prefer to have a chorus of people responding with lots of ideas instead of just one or two people throwing out thoughts, but since i think this is an important question, i'll try to respond…
in the immediate, short term, i think 2 things are important.
1- everyday needs might be a concern(food, travel, shelter, getting to school, day to day necessities- things that the family may have relied on their husband/father for)
2- i would think the kids and mother/wife would really benefit from therapy. if they're unwilling, mental and emotional support of friends and family can also be significant.
in the long term, there needs to be a strong, public, long-term condemnation of whatever values/idealogy motivated the father (if it was in any part son-preference). though each individual is responsible for his/her own actions, we aren't formed and we don't act in a vacuum. to some extent (how minor or major this is, is debatable), communities are responsible for what happens to the individuals they are made of.
i'm sure there are a lot of great ideas i left out…
tough question. i would prefer to have a chorus of people responding with lots of ideas instead of just one or two people throwing out thoughts, but since i think this is an important question, i’ll try to respond…
in the immediate, short term, i think 2 things are important.
1- everyday needs might be a concern(food, travel, shelter, getting to school, day to day necessities- things that the family may have relied on their husband/father for)
2- i would think the kids and mother/wife would really benefit from therapy. if they’re unwilling, mental and emotional support of friends and family can also be significant.
in the long term, there needs to be a strong, public, long-term condemnation of whatever values/idealogy motivated the father (if it was in any part son-preference). though each individual is responsible for his/her own actions, we aren’t formed and we don’t act in a vacuum. to some extent (how minor or major this is, is debatable), communities are responsible for what happens to the individuals they are made of.
i’m sure there are a lot of great ideas i left out…
I just got back from India last week and was lucky to be there for Lorhi. Maybe it was just the place I was in or maybe India is realising what it should, but I saw a few Lorhi celebrations for baby girls. And I was luck to be at one for my niece. Its really about time everyone stops this boy/girl nonsence and see be on the physical anatomy and learn that eveyones really the same.
I was in India for a month and there are way too many men. Sure celebrate them but lets also celebrate what got the men into the world. Suchi.
I'm 19 and I and my sisters had our first Lorhi 5 years ago. Even though it was a bit too late for a Lorhi, atleast everyone in my family is moving fwrd and not with the "old" mantality. With that they sort of set an example of some sort for others.
And killing your baby over being a girl is the MOST shittiest thing I have ever heard but its how the world turns. And I'd rather have it stop turning than have this happen
I just got back from India last week and was lucky to be there for Lorhi. Maybe it was just the place I was in or maybe India is realising what it should, but I saw a few Lorhi celebrations for baby girls. And I was luck to be at one for my niece. Its really about time everyone stops this boy/girl nonsence and see be on the physical anatomy and learn that eveyones really the same.
I was in India for a month and there are way too many men. Sure celebrate them but lets also celebrate what got the men into the world. Suchi.
I’m 19 and I and my sisters had our first Lorhi 5 years ago. Even though it was a bit too late for a Lorhi, atleast everyone in my family is moving fwrd and not with the “old” mantality. With that they sort of set an example of some sort for others.
And killing your baby over being a girl is the MOST shittiest thing I have ever heard but its how the world turns. And I’d rather have it stop turning than have this happen
I'm from Toronto, Canada and I attended a lohri party for a girl for the first time this year. The parents, second-generation, Canadian-born, made it a point to celebrate a lohri for their a daughter and give her the same celebration they did for their first-born son. They did lovely speeches in the beginning of the party both in english and punjabi, discussing the significance of lohri and why it's important that if you celebrate it, to do it equally for both sons and daughters. In my circle of family and friends, having lohri celebrations for sons and daughters equally is becoming normal and i'm grateful for that. What is also great, is that second-generation parents are making it more of a point to really provide significance and meaning behind the event, and make it more than just a party.
I’m from Toronto, Canada and I attended a lohri party for a girl for the first time this year. The parents, second-generation, Canadian-born, made it a point to celebrate a lohri for their a daughter and give her the same celebration they did for their first-born son. They did lovely speeches in the beginning of the party both in english and punjabi, discussing the significance of lohri and why it’s important that if you celebrate it, to do it equally for both sons and daughters. In my circle of family and friends, having lohri celebrations for sons and daughters equally is becoming normal and i’m grateful for that. What is also great, is that second-generation parents are making it more of a point to really provide significance and meaning behind the event, and make it more than just a party.
oops I meant to say sexist tradition-not religion. Unfortunately the culture is still strongly sexist. Thankfully my family does not celebrate this tradition-however being married to one that does-it just makes me feel disgusted. I can't see why if my grandparents were so liberal in their day and chose not to celebrate this tradition that second generation Indians still choose to do so, and think that they are 'modernizing' it by including girls-as if they are doing girls a favor. Just abolish the whole thing into nonexistence. I hope my furture children will not know one thing about this tradition at all.
Why not abolish this whole lorhi business. It stems from celebration of birth/marriage of a male. My grandparents never celebrated this tradition for their sons, and that was back in their day. I can't believe people still celebrate this sexist religion and think they are 'changin' it by now celebrating it for girls as well. It was not 'intended' for girls, and it should be abolished all together. If you want to celebrate-celebrate birthdays.
Why not abolish this whole lorhi business. It stems from celebration of birth/marriage of a male. My grandparents never celebrated this tradition for their sons, and that was back in their day. I can’t believe people still celebrate this sexist religion and think they are ‘changin’ it by now celebrating it for girls as well. It was not ‘intended’ for girls, and it should be abolished all together. If you want to celebrate-celebrate birthdays.
oops I meant to say sexist tradition-not religion. Unfortunately the culture is still strongly sexist. Thankfully my family does not celebrate this tradition-however being married to one that does-it just makes me feel disgusted. I can’t see why if my grandparents were so liberal in their day and chose not to celebrate this tradition that second generation Indians still choose to do so, and think that they are ‘modernizing’ it by including girls-as if they are doing girls a favor. Just abolish the whole thing into nonexistence. I hope my furture children will not know one thing about this tradition at all.
I understand your point Jaggi, but I think I have a contrary to both positions. I personally don't believe the celebration should be abolished nor just celebrated for women as a tag-on…In fact the tradition was 're-interpreted' and given fresh vitality by Sikh history.
Instead of Lohri, there was a replacement with Maghi and the celebration of the womenly heroic valour (or 'sheroism' as Jodha aptly called it) as well as a story of redemption and forgiveness with the Chali Muktay.
That is something definitely worth celebrating!
I understand your point Jaggi, but I think I have a contrary to both positions. I personally don’t believe the celebration should be abolished nor just celebrated for women as a tag-on…In fact the tradition was ‘re-interpreted’ and given fresh vitality by Sikh history.
Instead of Lohri, there was a replacement with Maghi and the celebration of the womenly heroic valour (or ‘sheroism’ as Jodha aptly called it) as well as a story of redemption and forgiveness with the Chali Muktay.
That is something definitely worth celebrating!
I'm off to attend my first Lorhi, as white guests of a Sikh family. The family is rather traditional. I am very much not! I have a difficult time with traditions that favour boys over girls… the Sikh host for this Lorhi tells us that traditions take time to change… however, it doesn't have to. A couple can simply say, "we equally value boys and girls, and choose to celebrate for the birth of an amazing human being".
My husband and I overruled many of many anglo-saxon traditions with our marriage, creating it as an equal partnership. My husband and I each keep our own last names, and our children will have a hyphenated name. This signifies, to us, that we are equal partners, and that our children belong to us both equally. This was to the slight dismay of both our families. Too bad.
I think that in all cultural traditions, we need to stand up for core values – that human beings have amazing worth and potential. Not just boys.
I’m off to attend my first Lorhi, as white guests of a Sikh family. The family is rather traditional. I am very much not! I have a difficult time with traditions that favour boys over girls… the Sikh host for this Lorhi tells us that traditions take time to change… however, it doesn’t have to. A couple can simply say, “we equally value boys and girls, and choose to celebrate for the birth of an amazing human being”.
My husband and I overruled many of many anglo-saxon traditions with our marriage, creating it as an equal partnership. My husband and I each keep our own last names, and our children will have a hyphenated name. This signifies, to us, that we are equal partners, and that our children belong to us both equally. This was to the slight dismay of both our families. Too bad.
I think that in all cultural traditions, we need to stand up for core values – that human beings have amazing worth and potential. Not just boys.
I just recently went to a Lohri Party for a baby girl. It was so much fun. There should not be any traditions that are strictly for men. This is just another way of controlling women, and it creates inequality amongst men and women. This is not how our Guru wanted women to be treated. As far as he was concerned men and women are equal. So throw parties for your girls hand out ludoos when they are born…. I know many people who celebrate festivities that are said to be for "boys' only. treat your girls as you would your boys ….If not Better. ;0)
I just recently went to a Lohri Party for a baby girl. It was so much fun. There should not be any traditions that are strictly for men. This is just another way of controlling women, and it creates inequality amongst men and women. This is not how our Guru wanted women to be treated. As far as he was concerned men and women are equal. So throw parties for your girls hand out ludoos when they are born…. I know many people who celebrate festivities that are said to be for “boys’ only. treat your girls as you would your boys ….If not Better. ;0)
Children are a gift from God, girl babies too! The world is getting smaller and things will change!
Children are a gift from God, girl babies too! The world is getting smaller and things will change!
A friend invited me to celebrate Lohiri. I had never heard the word and did not want to seem ignorate.__( I was born in Goa) I googled the term and read all the comments…and feel sad that we have to remind people to celebrate life of both sexes. Today brains are superior to brawn and parents may end up receiving more support from their daughters than their sons. Wisen up ladies . Socal change, sometimes disguised as religious dogma is usually initiated and supported by forward thinking women. Let us women, take a stand for equality , when ever we can . Start it from your heart and spread it from your inner circle to the community at large. With technology and a little detirmination we will make a difference. If the Punjabi women, who have the reputation of being strong, take a determined stand on this issue, the custom will change and we will rejoice and bless all babies. We will see it spreading fast and change will occure within this new decade.
A friend invited me to celebrate Lohiri. I had never heard the word and did not want to seem ignorate.__( I was born in Goa) I googled the term and read all the comments…and feel sad that we have to remind people to celebrate life of both sexes. Today brains are superior to brawn and parents may end up receiving more support from their daughters than their sons. Wisen up ladies . Socal change, sometimes disguised as religious dogma is usually initiated and supported by forward thinking women. Let us women, take a stand for equality , when ever we can . Start it from your heart and spread it from your inner circle to the community at large. With technology and a little detirmination we will make a difference. If the Punjabi women, who have the reputation of being strong, take a determined stand on this issue, the custom will change and we will rejoice and bless all babies. We will see it spreading fast and change will occure within this new decade.
We provide mobile pressure Sparkleen provide washing service to most of Southern Ontario. As our community grows, so does the need for the many services we offer. Fresh Water Supply toronto You can trust Sparkleen to provide exceptional service for the following applications.
We are industry leaders in graffiti removal. Garage Cleaning toronto Our expert staff remove unwanted vandalism from all surfaces and best of all we do it keeping the environment in mind.
Spring cleaning does not have to be painful, Garage Cleaning toronto stressful and clear. Huge selection of involving your children understand jobs that involve things moving (getting all the cushions of couches, outdoor carpet
"WOW! Great Article you can also Find Some Relevant. Girls captions
"
I didn’t know about expiring car seats until a somewhat recent discussion on MoneyNing, after which I realized that the seat I got at a garage sale was not only from an untrusted source, but also going to expire 2 months after my baby was supposed to be born. I knew I had to buy a new one, but the other one I bought wasn’t all for nothing – the place I bought the new one from had a trade-in sale where they accepted old items and gave you a hefty discount on the new item, so I ended up saving quite a bit (also included the baby shower discount for items that people didn’t buy). So it’s still possible to save money on something new if you look around. Also, my convertible seat is good for 8 years, so I will be using it until it expires and then just buy a booster seat.baby gate reviews
I wish I could reach through the computer and give you a hug. You are an amazing mama. Depression is so hard and it is so easy to silently suffer. Thank you for writing about your experience and being so honest. I know this post will help so many have the courage to reach out for help. For more visit vakn.com